The Chaos and Division in the U.S. House of Representatives: The Struggle to Elect a New Speaker

The recent events in the U.S. House of Representatives have caused a stir in the political landscape. After House Speaker Kevin McCarthy worked with Democrats to avert a government shutdown, House Republicans voted to remove McCarthy as their leader. This move has raised questions about the priorities of the Republican party and their loyalty to political power over the well-being of the American people.[0]

The anger from the most radical House Republicans stems from McCarthy's failure to fulfill the promises he made to secure his position as speaker. Moderate Republicans, on the other hand, are upset that Democrats did not support McCarthy after he took steps to avoid a government shutdown. Democrats, in turn, are frustrated that the entire shutdown drama could have been avoided if McCarthy had stuck to the deal he made to resolve the debt ceiling issue earlier in the year.

On October 3, Democrats joined dissident Republicans to remove McCarthy as speaker. This move was not surprising given McCarthy's reputation as an unreliable leader.[1] However, McCarthy's removal also presents an opportunity for Democrats to regain control of the House in 2024.[1] While McCarthy may have been ineffective as a speaker, he understood how to maintain GOP control.[1]

After McCarthy's removal, House Republicans held a meeting to elect their new leader.[2] Majority Leader Steve Scalise emerged as their nominee for speaker, narrowly defeating the Trump-endorsed candidate Jim Jordan.[2] However, Scalise soon realized that he did not have enough support to win the vote on the House floor, leading him to withdraw from the race.

By late Thursday, it seemed unlikely that Scalise would be able to secure enough GOP votes to be elected speaker. This deadlock highlights the power of a small faction of conservatives in sidelining the majority's agenda. With such a narrow majority, a speaker candidate can only afford to lose a few defections and still win.[3]

In their latest attempt to elect a speaker, House Republicans nominated Jim Jordan as their candidate.[4] However, more than 50 Republicans voted against supporting him on the House floor, leaving the party in disarray.[5] The inability to elect a speaker in the ten days since McCarthy's removal has left the House paralyzed.

The current state of the Republican Party in the House raises questions about how this deadlock will be resolved. Some speculate that Republicans may need Democrats' help to elect a speaker.[6] However, this outcome seems unlikely given the current political climate.

The situation in the House underscores the need for Republicans to unite behind a candidate who has the support of the majority of the conference.[2] Rules should be put in place to prevent the toppling of a speaker during the session by anyone who does not have more support.[2] However, the conference does not seem ready to adopt such rules, and the chaos is likely to continue until a leader is finally chosen.[2]

Jordan's emergence as the frontrunner for speaker has energized the far-right conservatives. However, his candidacy faces skepticism from more established Republicans who are concerned about his past as a Freedom Caucus founder.[7] Some centrist Republicans worry that Jordan's ultraconservative stances could jeopardize their fragile majority in swing districts.[7]

The path to electing a new speaker remains uncertain. Republicans are stuck in infighting, and it is unclear when this standoff will end and at what cost. The inability to secure the necessary votes has left the House in a state of paralysis.

The events surrounding the House speaker race have caused chaos and revealed the dangers of governing by chaos.[8] The removal of McCarthy and the subsequent struggle to elect a new speaker have alarmed the Washington establishment. Republicans must find a way to overcome their differences and unite behind a leader who can effectively lead the party.

In conclusion, the recent events in the U.S. House of Representatives have highlighted the divisions within the Republican party and the challenges they face in selecting a new leader. The inability to elect a new speaker has left the House in a state of paralysis and raised questions about the party's priorities. Republicans must find a way to come together and choose a leader who can unite the party and effectively govern. Only then can they move forward and address the pressing issues facing the American people.

0. “Readers respond: The price of Republican bipartisanship” OregonLive, 8 Oct. 2023,

1. “Democrats Can Win Big in 2024. But They Have to Fight for It.” The Nation, 12 Oct. 2023,

2. “Republicans Need to Get Their House in Order” National Review, 13 Oct. 2023,

3. “Congress is in shambles and failing America when it needs it most” Business Insider, 11 Oct. 2023,

4. “Scalise Drops Out of Speaker Race. Why a Leaderless House Is Bad for Bonds. – Barrons” Barron's, 13 Oct. 2023,

5. “GOP leadership crisis deepens as House remains paralyzed with no end in sight to speaker’s race” CNN, 13 Oct. 2023,

6. “Republicans Make Little Or No Progress In Effort To Find A Viable Speaker Candidate” KWTV, 13 Oct. 2023,

7. “House Speaker Stalemate Likely to Stretch Into Next Week” TIME, 13 Oct. 2023,

8. “The D.C. Establishment Doesn't Understand What Actual Chaos Is” The Federalist, 10 Oct. 2023,

Leave a Reply